Debunking the IPv6 Has More Security and QoS Myths

I thought that in the year 2011 …when the we’ve had so much talk about IPv6, lots of the smoke about what IPv6 is capable of and what it isn’t capable of would have cleared. Unfortunately not. Today I read this piece from CNET and I went “really? in this age, some major tech website still writes this kind of thing?”. Here are some of the claims they make about the new IPv6 ready DLink routers:

[a] “Enhanced network security: Plug in an IPv6-enabled D-Link router and the new security feature is automatically turned on.”

Exactly what new security feature are we talking about here? Just to clarify what has been done several times allover the web, even though implementation of IPsec is mandatory for IPv6, its usage is NOT and so IPv6 does not yield any new security benefits over IPv4. In fact, poorly managed, IPv6 is a security risk as it could completely bybass all that air-tight security you did for IPv4 on your network edge.

[b] “Increased network speeds and accessibility: As Web sites start to offer content over IPv6 and ISPs deploy IPv6 service, an IPv6-compliant router offers faster connection speeds and provides access to Web sites and applications that have transitioned. With its better design, IPv6 has integrated quality of service, so traffic is classified by voice, video, and data, and transported accordingly, resulting in faster network speeds.”

Puff!!!! Again, IPv6 doesn’t currently offer anything in QoS that IPv4 does not. And sorry to break it to you, but your connection speed is still going to depend upon how much bandwidth you have and not the IP version you are using.

To understand the source of this myth, look at the figure below which show the IPv4 header next to an IPv6 one. With respect to QoS, notice that:

  • The field responsible for QoS (specifically enables a packet to be marked for special treatment) in IPv4 was “ToS” ie Type of Service. This field is 8 bits long. In v6, the field was renamed to the more appropriate “Traffic Class” but same size and brings nothing new.
  • In IPv6, there is one new field … the “Flow Label” which is the source of this myth. The flow label in theory is meant to identify upper layer flows so that a router can identify upper layer flows without having to look beyong layer 3 (which could be time-consuming and slower). In reality, that field’s usage has not been defined and so it is currently unused. Therefore …right now, IPv6 offers nothing new to QoS that IPv4, thus making the assertion that IPv6 is faster false.

IPv4 and IPv6 Headers Compared

Even I used to propagate these myths which are based off of the original intentions of the IPv6 designers …but as time has gone on, we must do a reality check …the major benefit of IPv6 today is more address space and with that …maybe a return to the original end-to-end model of the Internet. Who know what cool innovations will result from that?

83 thoughts on “Debunking the IPv6 Has More Security and QoS Myths

  1. Oh, come on. Enough nay-saying, already. It’s true, I don’t like smoke and mirrors tactics too, and this sort of reporting and advertising is stretching it very, very, very thin, but myths?

    1. Speed: just wait till CGN is a couple of years in the making. Then IPv6 *will* be faster.

    2. QoS: nothing changes the fact that not maintaining state in the path is a terrific idea, so yeah, QoS flow label markings are almost certainly going to improve QoS as we know it.

    3. Security: this is the thorny one. Saying usage isn’t mandated means we can’t have more security than IPv4 is denial, plain and simple, but at the same time there’s nothing preventing IPv6 from being equally, or less, secure than IPv4 either. My personal assessment is that security will become more available, not less, because of host-to-host IPSec and tunnels that can’t happen due to the forests of NAT we’re all forced to live with.

    Cheers,
    Sabahattin

  2. Hi Sebahattin,

    My statement on speed didn’t factor in CGN …but sure …I can see your point. On the security point, IPv6 has the *potential* to be more secure (if you think IPSec) …but right NOW …it isn’t any more secure than v4 wouldn’t you agree?

    Thanks for the comments.

  3. Well, if we take the view that IPSec will not happen until we have IPv6, then yes, we don’t get any additional security benefit. However, remember that the advantages of IPSec are also conferred on those who get IPv6 using transitional techniques (tunnels), which may still be superior to trying to bolt it on IPv4 afterwards using NAT-traversal-friendly tunnel types (NAT-T, OpenVPN, TCP-over-TCP, etc) using cloak-and-dagger techniques, so I still maintain that “Security” is an acceptable, if very stretched, way to “Sell” IPv6.

    Thanks for indulging my rantings. :-)

    Cheers,
    Sabahattin

  4. 88888 He was young than she, so much more youthful that at first Janie dared not are convinced while in the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by wearing fall midsection and in depth neckline.

  5. 88888 He was more youthful than she, much younger that initially Janie dared not imagine with the contentment he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can greatly enhance their curves by sporting fall waist and thorough neckline.

  6. 88888 He was youthful than she, much younger that at the beginning Janie dared not believe that inside of the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can greatly enhance their curves by donning fall waist and thorough neckline.

  7. 88888 He was youthful than she, a great deal of young that in the first place Janie dared not imagine on the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by carrying drop waist and specific neckline.

  8. 88888 He was youthful than she, a great deal young that in the first place Janie dared not believe that with the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by putting on drop waist and thorough neckline.

  9. 88888 He was young than she, a lot young that initially Janie dared not consider within the contentment he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by sporting drop waist and comprehensive neckline.

  10. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot of youthful that at first Janie dared not trust in the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by putting on fall midsection and in-depth neckline.

  11. 88888 He was youthful than she, much more youthful that initially Janie dared not believe that inside of the joy he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by carrying fall waist and detailed neckline.

  12. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot of more youthful that in the first place Janie dared not presume while in the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by donning drop midsection and precise neckline.

  13. 88888 He was younger than she, a great deal of young that in the first place Janie dared not consider on the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by carrying drop waistline and thorough neckline.

  14. 88888 He was younger than she, much youthful that initially Janie dared not assume with the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by putting on fall waistline and in depth neckline.

  15. 88888 He was youthful than she, a great deal youthful that at the beginning Janie dared not believe that while in the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by wearing fall waist and comprehensive neckline.

  16. 88888 He was young than she, a great deal of younger that at first Janie dared not imagine in the contentment he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by carrying drop waistline and specific neckline.

  17. 88888 He was younger than she, a great deal youthful that at first Janie dared not feel from the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can greatly enhance their curves by donning fall waistline and in-depth neckline.

  18. 88888 He was young than she, a lot of youthful that at the beginning Janie dared not presume around the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by putting on fall waist and precise neckline.

  19. 88888 He was younger than she, much youthful that at the beginning Janie dared not presume on the contentment he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by wearing fall midsection and thorough neckline.

  20. 88888 He was young than she, much younger that in the first place Janie dared not are convinced during the contentment he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by sporting fall waistline and thorough neckline.

  21. 88888 He was more youthful than she, so much young that initially Janie dared not trust within the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by donning drop waistline and comprehensive neckline.

  22. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a lot young that at first Janie dared not imagine inside the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can greatly enhance their curves by carrying drop waist and in depth neckline.

  23. 88888 He was young than she, a lot youthful that at first Janie dared not assume from the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by wearing fall waist and thorough neckline.

  24. 88888 He was young than she, so much young that in the first place Janie dared not believe that inside of the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by donning fall waistline and thorough neckline.

  25. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a great deal of more youthful that initially Janie dared not believe that inside the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by carrying fall waist and comprehensive neckline.

  26. 88888 He was youthful than she, a great deal young that at the beginning Janie dared not believe while in the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by donning fall waistline and in-depth neckline.

  27. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot of youthful that at first Janie dared not think with the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by wearing drop waist and thorough neckline.

  28. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a great deal younger that in the first place Janie dared not believe during the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can greatly enhance their curves by sporting drop midsection and thorough neckline.

  29. 88888 He was young than she, a great deal younger that at first Janie dared not assume inside the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by wearing drop midsection and in-depth neckline.

  30. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot of youthful that at first Janie dared not consider within the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by carrying drop midsection and in-depth neckline.

  31. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot young that at first Janie dared not consider within the happiness he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by carrying fall waistline and in depth neckline.

  32. 88888 He was more youthful than she, much young that initially Janie dared not assume inside happiness he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by donning drop waistline and detailed neckline.

  33. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a great deal more youthful that in the first place Janie dared not think from the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by donning drop midsection and detailed neckline.

  34. 88888 He was young than she, a great deal of young that at the beginning Janie dared not assume inside of the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by carrying drop waist and thorough neckline.

  35. 88888 He was young than she, a lot more youthful that at first Janie dared not consider from the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by sporting fall waistline and specific neckline.

  36. 88888 He was youthful than she, a lot young that in the first place Janie dared not are convinced with the happiness he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by donning fall waistline and detailed neckline.

  37. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot of young that in the first place Janie dared not consider within the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by putting on fall midsection and in depth neckline.

  38. 88888 He was younger than she, so much younger that initially Janie dared not trust with the contentment he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by wearing drop midsection and specific neckline.

  39. 88888 He was youthful than she, a great deal younger that initially Janie dared not believe that with the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by donning drop midsection and in-depth neckline.

  40. 88888 He was young than she, so much younger that at the beginning Janie dared not believe that while in the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by wearing fall waist and detailed neckline.

  41. 88888 He was young than she, a lot of young that initially Janie dared not are convinced in the contentment he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by carrying fall midsection and detailed neckline.

  42. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a great deal younger that in the first place Janie dared not are convinced in the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by putting on drop midsection and in depth neckline.

  43. 88888 He was younger than she, a great deal of youthful that in the first place Janie dared not believe from the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by wearing drop waist and specific neckline.

  44. 88888 He was youthful than she, a lot more youthful that at the beginning Janie dared not think while in the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by putting on drop waistline and in depth neckline.

  45. 88888 He was young than she, a great deal of younger that initially Janie dared not imagine from the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by putting on fall midsection and thorough neckline.

  46. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot of more youthful that initially Janie dared not feel around the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by donning fall waist and in-depth neckline.

  47. 88888 He was youthful than she, a lot young that initially Janie dared not believe inside joy he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by donning fall waistline and in depth neckline.

  48. 88888 He was youthful than she, a great deal young that at first Janie dared not consider in the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by carrying drop midsection and comprehensive neckline.

  49. 88888 He was young than she, a lot youthful that at the beginning Janie dared not imagine while in the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by donning fall waist and in depth neckline.

  50. 88888 He was youthful than she, so much younger that at first Janie dared not feel inside the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can greatly enhance their curves by sporting fall waistline and in depth neckline.

  51. 88888 He was younger than she, a great deal of more youthful that in the first place Janie dared not feel from the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by donning fall waistline and thorough neckline.

  52. 88888 He was youthful than she, so much younger that in the first place Janie dared not think around the joy he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by sporting fall waistline and in-depth neckline.

  53. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a great deal of young that at first Janie dared not consider with the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by putting on drop midsection and thorough neckline.

  54. 88888 He was youthful than she, a lot younger that in the first place Janie dared not imagine while in the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by carrying fall midsection and detailed neckline.

  55. 88888 He was youthful than she, a lot of younger that at first Janie dared not imagine from the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by sporting drop waist and in depth neckline.

  56. 88888 He was youthful than she, a lot of young that at first Janie dared not believe within the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by wearing fall waist and thorough neckline.

  57. 88888 He was youthful than she, a lot more youthful that at the beginning Janie dared not presume from the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by wearing fall waist and in-depth neckline.

  58. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a great deal more youthful that in the first place Janie dared not presume in the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by putting on fall waistline and comprehensive neckline.

  59. 88888 He was younger than she, a great deal younger that at first Janie dared not assume inside of the happiness he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by putting on fall waist and thorough neckline.

  60. 88888 He was young than she, a great deal more youthful that initially Janie dared not believe that inside of the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by sporting drop midsection and in-depth neckline.

  61. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot of younger that at first Janie dared not imagine inside pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by sporting drop waist and in depth neckline.

  62. 88888 He was youthful than she, a great deal younger that at the beginning Janie dared not consider within the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by wearing fall midsection and in depth neckline.

  63. 88888 He was young than she, much more youthful that initially Janie dared not consider within the happiness he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by donning drop waist and in-depth neckline.

  64. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a lot of younger that at the beginning Janie dared not feel inside the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by sporting drop midsection and in-depth neckline.

  65. 88888 He was more youthful than she, much younger that at the beginning Janie dared not feel while in the joy he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by wearing drop waistline and thorough neckline.

  66. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a great deal of younger that in the first place Janie dared not trust while in the joy he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by carrying fall waistline and in depth neckline.

  67. 88888 He was youthful than she, so much more youthful that at first Janie dared not assume during the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by putting on drop waistline and specific neckline.

  68. 88888 He was youthful than she, so much more youthful that in the first place Janie dared not trust inside of the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by wearing fall waist and precise neckline.

  69. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a great deal of younger that at the beginning Janie dared not imagine during the joy he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by wearing drop waist and in depth neckline.

  70. 88888 He was younger than she, a lot of younger that at the beginning Janie dared not presume within the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by sporting drop waistline and in depth neckline.

  71. 88888 He was youthful than she, a great deal of young that at the beginning Janie dared not believe during the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enrich their curves by sporting fall waistline and precise neckline.

  72. 88888 He was young than she, a lot younger that at first Janie dared not trust in the happiness he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by sporting drop midsection and precise neckline.

  73. 88888 He was young than she, a great deal younger that at the beginning Janie dared not believe while in the joy he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can boost their curves by putting on drop midsection and precise neckline.

  74. 88888 He was younger than she, much young that initially Janie dared not trust in the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by wearing fall waist and comprehensive neckline.

  75. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a lot of more youthful that at first Janie dared not believe in the joy he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by donning fall waist and precise neckline.

  76. 88888 He was more youthful than she, much more youthful that initially Janie dared not think with the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can strengthen their curves by donning fall waist and comprehensive neckline.

  77. 88888 He was youthful than she, much young that in the first place Janie dared not are convinced within the joy he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by carrying fall waist and thorough neckline.

  78. 88888 He was more youthful than she, a lot of more youthful that initially Janie dared not believe that in the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by putting on fall midsection and in depth neckline.

  79. 88888 He was youthful than she, so much younger that initially Janie dared not think with the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by wearing fall waistline and detailed neckline.

  80. 88888 He was youthful than she, much youthful that in the first place Janie dared not imagine from the pleasure he brought to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by putting on drop waist and in-depth neckline.

  81. 88888 He was youthful than she, a lot more youthful that at the beginning Janie dared not consider on the happiness he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can enhance their curves by putting on drop waist and detailed neckline.

  82. 88888 He was more youthful than she, much young that at the beginning Janie dared not imagine during the contentment he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can improve their curves by carrying fall midsection and comprehensive neckline.

Leave a Reply